Free Content

Xing Yi Quan & The Nei Gong Classic – Part 3

The previous two posts, Xing Yi Quan & The Nei Gong Classic Part 1 & Part 2, laid the foundation of the internal alignments critical to Xing Yi Quan. The Nei Gong Classic then proceeds to go into great detail about the specifics of the body alignments in relation to internal connection and power.

The Head Must be Straight and Uplifted. The Shoulders Level and Aligned, the Chest Open Yet Shut.

The Feet Must Be Firm and Stable, The Knees Must Be Bent yet Extended, the Groin Must Be Deep and Concealed, the Ribs Must Be Open and Expanded.

These clauses relate directly to the requirements for performing San Ti Shi and Pi Quan. If the head is straight and uplifted there is vertical power in both directions. The head being straight and uplifted has many implications. Xing Yi’s 24 Points (Eight Character Rhyme) speaks of the Three Uplifts or Three “Propping Ups” (San Ding):

  1. The head presses upward
  2. The tip of the tongue touches the upper palate
  3. The hands press outward

Ding (顶) Literally means “to carry on the head,” to “push up from below,” or “to gore” or “butt.” Some Xing Yi practitioners describe this idea as a sense of the hair on the head “pushing up a hat.” When one employs Ding in relation to the head, the eyes can see clearly whether one is close or far – when one is far it is as though observing something close up; when one is close it is like observing something from a distance. This has great relevance to combat and self-defense, as well as spiritual advancement. When the head “Dings,” one feels regal and expansive. Then as it says in the Transported Spirit Classic, Jing Shen can soar, change and transform.

Raising up the head also extends the spine and opens the spinal cord so that Qi and marrow can flow freely, ascending to nourish the brain and spirit.

The position of the head is so critical that in the Nan Kua Jing (Received Trigrams Classic), the head is compared to the Qian-Heaven Hexagram with its six solid-yang lines pushing upward toward the heavens.

Qian-Heaven

The text says:

The head is symbolized by the Qian-Diagram, and governs the whole body as its chief. In terms of the origin, the head raises the Qi and blood of the whole body. In terms of smoothness, the head should follow the opponent tactfully, and should not be inattentively erect. In terms of advantage, the head must not be held askew or allowed to topple over, but rather it should be held straight and uplifted. Avoiding excessively lifting the face up or lowering the chin, and holding the head in a centered and upright position allows the Jing Shen to radiate, and allows one to be capable of confronting a strong opponent.

Further, the head should be upright without being tilted, and it should extend without using muscular force. It should not tilt and the chin should not be tucked downward nor face upward. Then in order to manifest strength and to exude power, which is the effect of the Qi, one must also watch the Hu Kou (Tiger’s Mouth) – the curved space between the thumb and forefinger. This relates to the hand pushing outward and helps sets the structure of the body, while simultaneously guiding Qi to the tips of the four limbs and the “Four Extremities” – the tips of the flesh, bones, sinews and blood, which are discussed in the Eight Necessities. The text goes on to say that Students who are unaware of these key points are incapable of great Gong Fu.

When uplifting the head, there can be a tendency to exert excessive muscular force which merely creates neck tension and prevents Qi from descending. Letting the tailbone sink downward aides uplifting the head and vice-versa. Master Song Zhi Yong’s advice is to imagine that you are wearing a shirt with a collar and that you simply relax the nape of your neck against the collar. This subtly lengthens the neck and puts the chin in a neutral position – neither too high nor too low.

The position of the tongue – propped, or lifted upward against the upper palate, aids the erect position of the head, while also connecting the Ren and Du Meridians in the mouth. Ren and Du are a bit like an electrical circuit. There are two connections that must be in place for the circuit to be fully connected, the perineum and the mouth. Hence the tongue tip lifts to touch the upper palate to complete the circuit above and the perineum and “grain duct” (anus) uplift and gather to complete the circuit below. Touching the tongue to the palate aids nasal breathing and prevents Qi from leaking out of the mouth. It also keeps the mouth and palate moist by stimulating saliva, which when swallowed returns a portion of the Jing (Essence) to the kidneys. Propping the tongue allows Qi to rise upward and to return again to Dan Tian. This in turn, fortifies Ming Men.

The shoulders must be level and aligned, upright and smooth in every direction. This enlivens the power of the shoulder blades and the projection of Jin into the arms and hands. For the shoulders to be level and aligned, the head must be upright and the elbows must sink. This refers to Xing Yi’s 24 Points and the Three Sinks or Three Drops (San Chui):

  1. Shoulders sink
  2. Elbows sink
  3. Qi sinks

The character Chui (垂) literally means “to sink,” “to drop,” “to hang down” or even “to droop.” The ancient character resembles a tree with drooping branches or a bough laden with leaves and drooping flowers. The importance of relaxing the shoulders, and sinking the shoulder blades and Shoulder Well (Jian Jing) have already been discussed. Chinese teachers often use the word Song in relation to relaxing the shoulders. Song (松) can refer to a pine tree, but it also means “to relax,” “slacken,” “loosen,” “free,” “let go,” or “untie.” The character conveys the idea of loosening one’s hair and letting it fall free by untying a cord that is binding it. This image is far more useful than just saying or thinking “relax the shoulders.”

The elbows in particular have a feeling of drooping, Martial arts teachers often explain Song by referencing its meaning in relation to a pine tree. A pine tree’s branches are supple and have an elastic quality. When covered with snow, they bend down and droop, but kick the snow off and they spring back up. The arms and body in general have this quality of Song – loose, but not lax. When the shoulders Song and sink, the arms are long and feel lively and the shoulders have a quality of pushing and driving the elbows forward. Master Song Zhi Yong adds that the elbows should have a quality of inward wrapping. The famous Xing Yi boxer Li Jian Qiu elaborates on this as follows:

Wrap the elbows, hang and droop the shoulders, swell the abdomen, open (spread out) the chest. Wrapping the elbows keeps the arms curved so that power from the shoulders can be transmitted to the hands. This is a key point in Xing Yi Quan that should not be forgotten or left out. For example, in Pi Quan (Splitting Fist) the power of the whole body must be able to reach the tips of the fingers. If a person’s fingers are weak, how can he strike a person and throw him out more than 3 meters away? Furthermore, if one does not know the fingers are weak, but uses the power of the whole body gathered together what could be the difficulty.

If the elbows are not wrapped, the arms will be stiff and power will stop and the arms and not emit outward. By testing these points, they can be understood. Hanging and drooping the shoulders keeps Qi from floating upwards so that it gathers in the lower abdomen. If you do not drop your shoulders, it will be hard to keep it [Qi]  there.[1]

When the elbows sink or droop, then the forearms and elbows can protect the ribs and the vital points in between the ribs. Loosening and sinking the shoulders and ribs allows Qi to descend to Dan Tian which in turn makes the body stable like a mountain.

The chest must be open but is not thrust forward. It has a quality of soft restraint, of being gently withdrawn. Therefore, it is both open and closed at the same time. Li Jian Qiu explains this as follows:

Swelling the abdomen, refers to gathering Qi in the lower abdomen. In the human body there are two places to store Qi. One is the lungs and the other is the lower abdomen below the navel. When Qi is stored in the lungs, in a short time it must be released. This is due to respiration. However, when Qi is stored in the lower abdomen the respiration of the lungs will not leak. Storing Qi in this way, does not obstruct or hinder respiration and Qi can open and unfold fully and one can grasp and hold it for a long time. If it is not this way then when fighting one will pant and gasp, become flushed in the face, one’s heart will pound, veins will distend alarmingly.

Opening the chest means that accumulated Qi will not interfere with respiration. Although one is constantly gathering Qi in the lower abdomen, if one forces the Lung Qi to descend to the lower abdomen making the chest flat, this inhibits the lungs and hinders respiration, which is injurious to one’s health. Even though one is arousing Qi in the lower abdomen the lungs must be allowed to expand freely in order to prevent harm.[2]

Opening the chest means that it is somewhat hollow. This rounds the back, which helps Qi extend into the arms while simultaneously allowing Qi to sink downward. Open and close are two sides of the same coin. If the chest is open, it has a potential for closing. If withdrawn slightly it has the potential to open. This gives one the ability to issue power through this opening and closing.

The next clause begins with: The feet must be firm and stable. The feet are rooted in the ground without any sensation of shaking, or instability. Stability in the legs and feet is to some degree a function of the back extending power downward and sinking the Shoulder Well (Jian Jing), as was mentioned earlier. As the shoulders sink, the back sends force downward, aiding the ability of Qi to move upward from Yong Quan (Kid 1) on the sole of the foot. Many Xing Yi Masters advise that the five toes must grasp the ground, however exerting physical force in the feet and toes creates tension and makes it difficult for the body to move suddenly. Hence one should think of the feet as suction cups, like medical glass cupping sets that create suction by using a pump to draw air out of the cup. This “suction” comes largely from above (uplifted head, round crotch, shoulders dropping, tail sinking under, etc.), as well as from the contact points of the foot with the ground. Master Song Zhi Yong says that it is incorrect to have the feet “grip” the ground when standing in San Ti Shi – rather the feet are like the hydraulic outrigger stabilizing feet on a crane truck which adhere to the ground and create a large surface that clamps to the ground for stability.

This image of the hydraulic feet is an interesting image because it connects with another set of Xing Yi Quan’s 24 points (Eight Character Rhyme): San Kou. The character Kou (扣) can mean “to button,” “to buckle up,” “to clamp,” or “cover with a concave object.” The Three “Clampings” are:

  1. The shoulders blades clamp
  2. The backs of the hands and feet clamp
  3. The teeth lightly clamp

When the two shoulders blades Kou or clamp, the chest becomes empty and Qi and Jin-Li (force) extend outward to the elbows. When the back of the hands and feet clamp, Qi and Jin-Li go to the hands and feet and the body is rooted and the steps are strong and balanced. This reiterates the earlier discussion of dropping the shoulders and shoulder blades and connecting Jian Jing (GB 21) and Qu Chi (LI 11) with Yong Quan (Kid 1). When the teeth clamp, the tendons and bones contract and the bones of the body are connected and strong. Clamping the teeth means they close together without force and without grinding the teeth – the jaw is neither slack nor is it tense. All three “clampings,” particularly clamping the teeth, must be a product of the intention and not the forceful contraction of the muscles and sinews.

What is really interesting about the three “clampings” is that they are completely intertwined as part of the larger body pattern. It is difficult for the hands and feet to clamp unless the teeth also clamp. And clamping the teeth also aids clamping and sinking the shoulder blades.

Placing the tip of the tongue on the roof of the mouth (one of the Three Ding – “pushing up from below”), and clamping the teeth together very lightly are also part of one of the Eight Necessities of Xing Yi Quan: being “Orderly[3] in the Four Extremities” (四梢要齊 Si Shao Yao Qi). Liu Wen Hua, son of the great Liu Qi Lan describes the Four Extremities as follows:

It is necessary to touch (prop up) the roof of the mouth with the tongue, knock the teeth, hold the fingers and toes inwards, and tighten the hair pores. When the tongue touches the palate, body fluid (saliva) can concentrate ensuring the smooth circulation of Qi and blood. When the teeth are knocked tightly, Qi is able to flow into bone marrow. When the fingers and toes are drawn inward, Qi is able to pour into the sinews. When the hair pores are tightened, Qi in the whole body can gather and be solid. To be “tidy” means that in every posture, there is unity in touching the roof with the tongue, knocking the teeth, drawing the fingers and toes inward and tightening the hair pores. If one of the four is absent, the Qi will be scattered and power weakened, so there is little purpose in discussing martial skills.[4]

Fingers and toes drawn inward refers to Yong Quan having a hollow, lifted feeling through the connections previously mentioned and the palm center, Lao Gong (P 8 – “Palace of Labor”) having a sense of withdrawing. These actions not a product of muscular force but of the dropped shoulders, wrapped elbows. This also relates to “clamping.”

The concept of Ding, “carrying on the head,” or “propping or pushing up from below,” was discussed earlier. Some Xing Yi practitioners describe this idea as a sense of the hair on the head “pushing up a hat,” while others like Liu Wen Hua (above) say that the hair on the body stands up when the Four Extremities are ordered, integrated and unified. Master Song Zhi Yong several times showed me how the hair on his arms was standing up after training San Ti Shi or Tu Na Si Ba. Below is another description of the four extremities by Li Jian Qiu.

Firstly, there is the head hair. It has nothing to do with the organs or limbs, and thus would appear to be irrelevant, but the hair is the extremity of the blood, and the blood is the sea in which the energy swims. The hair should be pushing up under the cap. This indicates that the blood is sufficient or full. The tongue is then the antenna for the muscles. The muscles are like a sack that holds Qi. If Qi is not able to reveal itself in the extremity of the flesh, then Qi is not at full capacity. Therefore, the tongue wanting to press the teeth, this indicates that the muscles (flesh) are filled with Qi. The teeth are the extremity of the bones, the nails are the extremity of the sinews. Qi is born in the bones and unites with the sinews. If Qi is not apparent in the teeth, it will also not be present in the nails. The teeth must want to bite through the sinews and nails must want to penetrate through bone. Then the four extremities are full and the Qi is also replete.[5]

The character Shao (梢) means “tip,” or “twig,” as in the top of a tree or the end of a branch. In relation to the Four Extremities, the tip implies where something ends and connects to the outside world. This means that when the Four Extremities are filled with Qi, then Qi and force can be released outward. In relation to Fa Jin and Fa Li when engaging with an opponent, the tongue must lift up to the palate so the flesh tip is integrated. When the wrist and ankle fill and open, the sinew tip is integrated. When the teeth come together, the bone tip is integrated. When the Four Tips are integrated, internal force and power can be released.[6]

Science & The Four Extremities

If the theory of the Four Extremities seems a bit strange, recent scientific experiments give some credence to the importance of placing the tip of the tongue on the upper palate and lightly clenching the teeth during exercise.

One study, which explored the effect of tongue position in the mouth on knee isokinetic test performance, showed a 30% increase of knee flexion peak torque when the tip of the tongue is touching the hard palate between the upper front teeth, the interdental papilla, and the first fold of the roof of the mouth, as compared with the tongue touching the inner surfaces of the front teeth or lying low on the lower teeth. Both acceleration and power variables increased with the tongue tip on the upper palate behind the upper teeth.[7]

Another study showed that lightly clenching the teeth during exercise enhanced performance and joint movement by improving the tendon reflex in distant muscles and by inhibiting contraction of antagonist muscles.[8] A series of studies have shown the positive effect of teeth clenching in relation to grip strength, while yet another series of studies found that clenching the teeth during activities involving the limbs can enhance neuro-motor stimulation.[9]

Notes:

[1] The Art of Xing Yi Quan 形意拳術 Li Jian Qiu (1919)

[2] The Art of Xing Yi Quan 形意拳術 Li Jian Qiu (1919)

[3] Qi 齊: Orderly, Neat, Unified, Even; Together; Integrated

[4] A Detailed Collection of the Art of Xing Yi Qua , Liu Wen Hua (Liu Dian Chen), 1920, translated by Tom Bisio and Huang Guo Qi

[5] 形意拳術 The Art of Xingyi Boxing, 李劍秋 by Li Jian Qiu (1919). Translation by Tom Bisio and Huang Guo Qi.

[6] 曹繼武:十法 Cao Ji Wu’s Ten Methods, translated by Tom Bisio & Huang Guo Ji. Cao Ji Wu. Cao Ji Wu was a famous master of Xing Yi Quan. Cao Ji Wu is said to have studied with Ji Jike in the 17th century and is believed to be the teacher of Dai Long Bang, purportedly the first generation of the Shanxi branch of Xing Yi practitioners.

[7] The acute effect of the tongue position in the mouth on knee isokinetic test performance: a highly surprising pilot study.” Rosa Di Vico et als (Muscles Ligaments and Tendon Journal 2013 Oct-Dec; 3(4), p. 318–323

[8] Hirabayashi R, Edama M, Saito A, Yamada Y, Nawa R, Onishi H. Effects of Clenching Strength on Exercise Performance: Verification Using Spinal Function Assessments. Sports Health. 2022 May-Jun;14(3):404-414. doi: 10.1177/19417381211014836. Epub 2021 May 29. PMID: 34053343; PMCID: PMC9112714

[9] Souza, Bárbara & Carteri, Randhall & Lopes, André & Teixeira, Bruno. (2021). Teeth clenching can modify the muscle contraction strength of the lower or upper limbs: systematic review. Sport Sciences for Health. 17. 1-12. 10.1007/s11332-021-00741-y.